MLB · Baseball · Jul 19, 2026 15:10 EDT · avg book margin 8.7%

Colorado RockiesvsCincinnati Reds

Totals split wide: 3.4% edge surfaces with 24 hours to first pitch

What happened: Final score: 6–9. The edge paid: the flagged side won, returning +1.05 units on a flat 1-unit stake. The closing line moved against the signal (-13.4% CLV) — honest note: on this one, the market did not confirm the edge. For the record: the flagged price stayed live for about 24 hours after detection before the edge closed.
Offered2.05Fair price1.98+3.4% above fair

The setup — the analysis as published at detection, written 23.6 hours before start and frozen for the record. The market it describes has since closed; the outcome is above.

The over-under for Colorado Rockies vs Cincinnati Reds (MLB) is priced unevenly across sportsbooks. One side of the totals market is currently quoting 3.4% above where independent sharp operators have calibrated fair value. The mispricing is live now, not hindsight — odds remain quoted as this page loads.

When bookmakers scatter this wide, it signals genuine disagreement about where the true line sits. Sharp consensus converges on what that true line is — and today it points to a clear side.

The consensus behind this edge draws from 4 independent sharp sources, so the fair-value estimate is not one book's isolated read.

The edge aligns with 11 patterns logged in the Playbook archive. The highest-performing variant has returned +14.7% on closed bets.

This exact market segment — baseball totals at mid-range odds — has a measurable track record: 1186 resolved bets in our database show +2.8% ROI.

These mispricings do not hold until first pitch. Comparable edges in this market have historically compressed within roughly 20 hours as sharp capital realigns the totals.

Historical, aggregate data on settled bets — not betting advice and not a guarantee. Markets adapt; edges fade; variance is real.

AN EXAMPLE OF THE MEMBER VIEW · what members see on a bet like this — shown for a different, already-settled match PRO
Cincinnati Reds vs St. Louis Cardinals · MLB · Baseball — flagged side Under 8.5 @ 2.15
79 Omen Score

This is the complete breakdown members get for every live signal. The example below is a DIFFERENT match, already settled — its market is closed, so full disclosure costs nothing. Everything is real except values marked 🔒, which are members-only (decoy digits shown).

Why this bet
+4.4%
Entry edge
+0.9%
Edge near close
+0.1%
Risk-adjusted edge
2.13
Fair price (no-vig)
2.25
Entry odds
Quality
80/100
Confidence
9
Sharp books
Prime signal
Class
Market state: Recreational consensus (no sharp anchor) · priced from: Market reference
Sizing
1.55%
Recommended stake
0.8%
Full Kelly (theoretical max)
Insights
Rec-book consensus only — no sharp anchor.High confidence + meaningful price gap — best risk-adjusted segment.
A sample of bookmakers on this betnear close — every price against the same no-vig fair
BookmakerOddsVs fair
Hard Rock2.15+0.9%
espn-bet2.10-1.4%
Hard Rock2.10-1.4%
1xBet2.08-2.3%
Matchbook2.08-2.3%
sport8882.05-3.8%
betparx1.96-7.9%
Bally Bet1.96-7.9%
BetRivers1.96-7.9%
PMU1.83-14.3%
Risk & profitability profile
Heavy favoriteFavoriteCoin flipUnderdogLongshot
2.15 odds → 47% implied win probability
47%
Fair win probability
+4.9% 🔒
Expected ROI (model)
+8.0% 🔒
Cohort realized ROI
The endingthe part only a settled signal can show
Detected Aug 17, 18:51 UTC at 2.25 (+4.4% edge) → fair price at close 2.13 → closing-line value +1.1%
✅ Settled: WON · +1.25 units
A real, settled example — not a typical-results claim (read this signal's full story). The live breakdown for Colorado Rockies vs Cincinnati Reds is on the member board now · unlock with Pro
See the live board — free account

The strategies behind signals like this · More stories

Record settled · last updated Jul 19, 2026 22:02 UTC · How these numbers are made: methodology · the dataset — fair prices shown are margin-free. Spotted an error? Request a correction (include this page's URL).